I’m tired and grumpy
December 19, 2006My friend and I were talking today during our block 1 open, and we both came to a disagreement on Mark Twain. She did put me down at first, telling me that I was making a generalization on American literature, which I guess was true (after all, I do enjoy Thoreau and Hawthorne.) Unfortunately, our arguement didn’t get intellectual or anything, since two of our friends sat at the table with us, telling us about their craving for bagels. Luckily, we did compare British romantic literature (i.e. Oscar Wilde) and “true” American literature (i.e. Mark Twain). Inevitably, I argued for Oscar Wilde, claiming that his work is so witty and brilliant, in addition to being beautiful. Wilde, is a man who was capable of almost anything literary. He had wonderful dramatic work such as “The Picture of Dorian Gray,” and the light-hearted and intelligent “The Importance of Being Earnest.” Personally, I believe that “The Importance of Being Earnest” is the epitome of a witty play, and the satire on British aristocracy is sheer brilliance. After getting this far into my arguement, I noticed that she just didn’t care anymore, and she had no desire to snap back with some “witty” (if you can even call it that) reference in Huck Finn. That to me, made me believe that if she had no passion in her to defend Mark Twain, then what type of author is he? Whenever I enjoy an author, especially one from the British romantic period, I feel compelled and almost obligated to defend them. That is what a truly good author is supposed to be, that is how much of a good book it should be. If Huck Finn is such an amazing American Literature novel, why is it that whenever I criticize it, no one ever comes to its defense? This leads me to another point, does anyone ever truly enjoy this book? Maybe the true and core reason why students enjoy this book, is because it’s almost programmed in their head to like Mark Twain. My friend was the perfect example, she liked Huck Finn, but didn’t explain why she liked him, the only thing she did say was “he’s awesome.” Well, I don’t think that one word comments will get very far without a solid explaination or argument. I wanted to inquire, ask more, I really wanted her to convince to like this book, but she was no help.
To be absolutely honest, when I began reading Huck Finn, I forced myself to like it, I made myself smile, I made myself giggle. I wanted to like it, I really did. But as I read on, I realized that this book was just not for me, it wasn’t anything that I enjoyed, and it certainly isn’t anything I find witty.
Posted by Norma